3 4
Interviews: Whenever you are meeting with
a committee, remember not to take things
personally. The dynamics of the committee
are certain to involve issues that arose
long before your visit. This is true for the
job talk as well; sometimes listeners will
ask questions that seem irrelevant because
they are trying to make a point about a
departmental issue. The key is to treat all of
these situations with good grace and move
forward.
One of the biggest and most exciting
challenges for those interviewing for
academic positions, particularly if it is
the first year you are in the academic job
market, is the shift in role. No longer are
you perceived as a student! Many PhD
candidates have returned from on-campus
interviews remarking on their surprise at
being received as a colleague. The audience
at your job talk is not like your dissertation
committee. Be prepared for different kinds
of questions—more along the lines of
questions one colleague would ask another,
as opposed to those that a professor would
ask a student.
Common sense and courtesy rule the day
in how to conduct oneself at an on-campus
interview. Avoid or minimize alcohol
at meals (positions have been lost after
inebriated candidates made statements they
would later regret). Treat everyone you
encounter—students, staff, faculty, and
administrators—with respect, consider-
ation, and interest. Resist the temptation to
vent or complain at any point during the
day to anybody. If the flight was tedious
or you don’t care for the campus archi-
tecture, save those details for private phone
conversations later. For some reason, the
temptation to let down one’s guard and
vent is especially great when walking from
one appointment to another with a member
of the search committee or a student. Strive
to maintain the pleasant and engaging
demeanor you had during the interviews.
Chalk Talks
Chalk talks are sometimes included in the
academic science and technology interview
structure. Think of these as a more
advanced “quals.” They usually include
members of the search committee and
faculty from other departments. Organize
your talk similar to an R01 to explain the
significance of your research and your plans
for developing a successful research plan.
Preparing for an Academic Job Talk
When you’re invited to give an academic
job talk at an on-campus interview, it’s
an exciting opportunity to enhance your
candidacy and share your work! The right
preparation will help you prepare and
deliver a successful talk.
Expectations can vary by campus and by
department, so it’s important to find out
what to expect. How long a talk does your
host expect? Who and how many will be
in the audience? Is this a seminar or a
class? Is this on your dissertation…or on
anything but your dissertation? Should
you bring copies of your talk to distribute?
If you need audio-visual technology (a
projector, the necessary cables, an LCD
screen, etc.), will they be supplied? At
what time of day will your talk be held
(and is there a way you can build a break
in before the talk, so you have some time
to catch your breath and prepare mentally
and emotionally)? Where will you speak,
and will there be time afterward to take
questions?
Your advisor and other faculty in your
discipline can be an extraordinarily
valuable resource as well. Talk to them
to find out the conventions, norms, and
traditions surrounding academic job talks
in your field. Solicit their perspectives
on how you should dress, whether you
should bring copies of your paper and/
or use technology, and to what level
you should pitch your talk. Strategically
speaking, what do your advisor and
others know about the department and
the people with whom you’ll be talking?
How can you find out more about them?
What questions should you be prepared
to answer? Are there any “land mines” for
which you should be prepared?
As you compose your talk, ensure that
you set a context, showing the impor-
tance of your research. Answer the “So
what?” question, and demonstrate how
your work is related to major issues in the
field. Indicate not only what you’ve done,
but what you will be doing in the future.
Then try to find or create opportunities
to practice your talk for others. Ask them
if they think you’ve found the right level
for the talk (one professor described it
as “sophisticated but not specialized”).
Do you seem simultaneously prepared
and spontaneous? Are you prepared to
handle questions seriously and courte-
ously, without getting defensive? And was
the talk interesting? If you plan to use
slides during your talk, be sure to include
them in your practice as well. Talk to the
audience, not to the screen!
One terrific strategy is to anticipate
questions beyond your presentation and
develop slides (in addition to those that
you will use in your talk) “in reserve” for
topics about which you might be asked,
or for details that might be difficult to
remember off the top of your head. For
instance, if a faculty member asks, “Did
you perform any statistical analyses?”
you can say, “Yes, I did—in fact, I have
a summary of the statistical results right
here,” and put up your reserve slide. You
can put these reserve slides at the end of
your presentation, or if you are presenting
using a laptop, you can save the slides
in another presentation file entirely, so
that you don’t accidentally initiate them at
the end of your presentation. Of course,
when planning to include any type of
technology in your talk, be sure to set it
up in advance—and have a backup plan
in place if it doesn’t work.
When it comes time to deliver the talk
at your interview, consider introducing
yourself individually to audience members
as they arrive, instead of isolating yourself
at the front of the room. It can be helpful
to imagine that these are friends and
supporters sitting in the audience. In fact,
these people might indeed become your
friends and colleagues one day soon!
Many students have reported a feeling
of surprise at presenting to appreciative
listeners who respond as they would to
a colleague, not to a graduate student.
In fact, sharing your research or a topic
that interests you can be a very rewarding
experience.
PhD students can get feedback and
advice on job talks at the Hume Center
for Writing and Speaking. For more infor-
mation, visit undergrad.stanford.edu/
tutoring-support/hume-center.
Adapted from the Stanford University Oral
Communication Program