Wilson Sonsini has 19 offices in technology and business hubs worldwide.
For more information, visit wsgr.com/offices.
Legal Landmines Every Startup Should Avoid
Legal issues are the last thing most founders want to think about when forming a new company. One of the biggest mistakes that startups
and their founders often make is not involving counsel early in the life of the business to navigate a variety of difficult and sometimes
complex legal obstacles, including company formation, equity grants, capital raising, intellectual property protection, securities laws
compliance, and labor and employment law compliance. The following high-level summary (i) identifies many of these legal landmines,
any of which can delay or complicate business operations, and/or negatively impact the company’s ability to raise capital and, ultimately,
its prospects, and (ii) suggests ways to help manage and mitigate the risks associated with those issues.
1. Failing to Form a Business Entity (Early)
Limit your personal liability. Form or incorporate a Limited Liability Corporation (LLC), Limited Partnership or Corporation.
Generally, the entity’s assets are on the hook liability-wise and investors’ liability is limited to the amount invested.
Keep it simple. It is typically preferable to structure the business as a Delaware C-corporation for companies that plan to get venture
capital funding.
2. Paying Too Little Attention to Corporate Formalities
Piercing the corporate veil. This legal doctrine applies when a plaintiff is allowed to look beyond the business entity to recover
damages from the business’s owners. Minimize such risk by adequately capitalizing the entity, ensuring that there is no co-mingling
of personal and entity funds in a single bank account and conducting all business activities through the entity (e.g., the entity should
be party to agreements).
3. Failing to Appropriately Address Equity
Properly approve and document all equity issuances and grants. All equity issuances and grants have to be approved by the board of
directors (or equivalent) to be valid. All oral agreements need to be properly documented.
Create and maintain a capitalization table. Record ownership percentages among the founders and any other owners of the business.
Founders’ stock and employee equity. Founders’ stock is usually issued at a nominal price and subject to vesting (a repurchase right
by the company that lapses over time). Companies that plan to offer stock options to employees need 409A valuations. A 409A
valuation is an appraisal of the fair market value of a company’s common stock that determines the exercise price for options.
Granting options without a 409A valuation risks adverse tax consequences.
4. Failing to Raise Enough Capital
Comply with securities laws. All offers and sales of securities must be SEC registered or have valid exemptions from federal and state
registration or qualification requirements. Consult with qualified securities counsel before issuing any securities to non-founders.
Do not fear dilution (too much). Raise as much capital as you can when you can. A company never went out of business due to
dilution.
Fundraising is all-consuming. Raising capital distracts the founder(s)/management team from just focusing on growing the business.
Spend money wisely. Hire conservatively and purposefully. Consider equity compensation (with vesting). Keep in mind that things
tend to cost twice as much and take twice as long as expected.
5. Failing to Protect Intellectual Property (IP)
Use IP assignments. Ensure that IP contributed by founders, employees, consultants, advisors, or any other service providers is
owned by (or securely licensed to) the business.
Develop and implement a comprehensive IP strategy. An IP strategy should cover IP creation, acquisition, and protection, and should
anticipate growth. IP includes utility patents, design patents, plant patents, trade secrets, trademarks and copyrights.
Use confidentiality & non-disclosure agreements. Before sharing or discussing the company’s IP or confidential information with any
third party, consider requesting that the third party execute a non-disclosure agreement.
6. Not Checking for Availability When Naming the Company and Products
Search for existing trademarks and tradenames. Selecting a company or product name should take into account existing trademark
and tradename searches, which are relatively inexpensive to commission. Not all names can be trademarked (e.g., a name that is
purely descriptive). Also, consider whether preferred domain names are available.
7. Not Having Key Documents from the Start
Put key documents in place. At a minimum, the following key documents should be in place at the beginning among founders and
with any employee or service provider:
Among Founders:
IP Assignment Agreements
Key Corporate Documents
All Employees or Other Service Providers:
Offer letter or employment agreement
Properly drafted bonus and commission plans, if offering such incentive compensation
Proprietary information and inventions assignment agreement, including protection for confidential and proprietary
information and trade secrets of the business, plus any necessary restrictive covenants for employees
Arbitration agreements or other alternative dispute resolution policies, if desired by the business
Key employment policies, often in the form of an employee handbook or compliance manual
Proper consulting, contractor, or advisor agreements for other service providers
8. Failing to Properly Classify Employees and Independent Contractors
Know the classification rules. Determine whether each service provider is classified as an employee or contractor. For employees,
determine whether each individual is properly classified as exempt or non-exempt from overtime and is properly paid under state
and federal law. Once the proper classification has been determined, all service providers must sign formal agreements assigning all
IP rights to the company and agreeing to keep the company’s IP confidential.
9. Misunderstanding the Scope of Restrictive Covenants
Know the scope of restrictive covenants and how they can impact the business. First and foremost, any business, especially startups,
should be aware of, to the extent possible, restrictions on service providers the business intends to hire or may have employed,
especially founders and key personnel. These restrictions can include, in addition to IP assignment, non-compete, non-solicitation,
no-hire, non-interference, and related provisions. Ignoring these can potentially result in costly litigation and potential injunctive
relief prohibiting the use of an employee, product sales, and distribution as well as disputes over lost profits.
10. Failing to Understand and Abide by Applicable Wage and Hour Rules
Understand the relevant wage and hour laws. Every business should ensure compliance with the wage and hour laws applicable in
each city and state where the business maintains employees, regardless of the size and number of employees. Wage and hour laws
govern a variety of compensation scenarios, including minimum wage, overtime, how bonuses and commissions must be handled,
severance, layoffs, accrued vacation time, and other areas. Failure to understand these rules can result in class actions, wage and
hour audits, tax audits, and a variety of other costly legal disputes, which can quickly drain company time and resources.
11. Indiscriminately Using Social Media
Be careful in the use of social media, especially in the hiring or termination of an employee. While informative, using social media
during the hiring process may lead to failure to hire claims, as well as unintended harm based on learning that an employee is in a
protected category. Similarly, when terminating an employee, use of social media may lead to a variety of other legal pitfalls, especially
if posts and use of such social media by the employee is the reason or becomes one of the reasons for terminating the employee.
12. Assuming all States Have the Same Laws and Legal Standards
Before branching into other states, be sure you know the ground rules for doing business there, including on each of the issues in this
summary. Importantly, there are multiple overlapping rules and regulations relating to business operations, which create many
variations between state and federal government, between two states, and even between cities. Accordingly, do not assume, for
example, that you can use forms or policies for Texas employees for employees in other states (or countries for that matter).
For more information, please contact:
Brandon Middleton-Pratt
Of Counsel
512-338-5406
This communication is for informational purposes only. It is not intended to create an attorney-client relationship
or constitute an advertisement, a solicitation or professional advice as to any particular situation.
Wilson Sonsini has 19 offices in technology and business hubs worldwide.
For more information, visit wsgr.com/offices.
© 2023 Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, Professional Corporation. All rights reserved.